I spoke with a woman a few days ago who’d bought some residential rental properties at the height of the market in 2007. I don’t know what the loan to value ratio was, but her rental income was slipping behind the mortgage payments. All she needed was a loan modification getting the interest rate down to five percent and wasn’t getting anywhere with her lender.
Hers was one of several I’ve run into over the past month or so where low-level investors can’t get the same help that’s available to people who knowingly bought a home they couldn’t afford with a loan whose underwriting was a rumor. If someone has a Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac loan that’s 125% of the market value of the house, help is on the way.
Last time I checked, investors accounted for about twenty percent of the upside down loans. That’s not an insignificant number. These are folks who took advantage of the market as they perceived it and the tax laws at the time to try to make a few dollars, and now they’re in trouble. But Fannie, Freddie, et al give them a pejorative term’—“flippers—“ and deem they aren’t worthy of help.
And Bear Sterns IS worthy? And Bank of America and Wells Fargo? And JP Morgan Chase and AIG?
I don’t have evidence to prove it, but I’m going to venture a guess that these small-time investors are probably among the more creditworthy of upside down owners. A significant loan modification—even if it has a three- to five-year fuse—may well keep a significant number of homes out of the REO class. To flat out refuse help is flat out wrong.
Having lived through the S & L crisis, my guess is that cooler heads will prevail. Lenders, at some point, will have to figure out how to write off loan balances while minimizing hits to their capital. In the case of investors, a short-term interest holiday might very well yield a good bit of relief.
The number of rentals in the Orenco area will continue to increase as more and more people are unable to sell at an acceptable price. Stabilizing mortgages of small-time investors stabilizes our neighborhood.